How do you handle a product url when a brand has the same product type in different shapes?
Let me provide you with an example. I have Brand A that has sling bags. There is a sling bag, and there is a long sling bag. The shape and design of these 2 bags are totally different from each other.
Normally I would have a like like this:
I was thing thinking in the line of:
Then you have 2 different product URLs differentiated by their IDs. But to me this still looks almost like the same URL.
..but I would prefer to keep a sling bag a sling bag.
Any suggestions? Will I be penalised by the search engines if I go for option 1?
I founf an example, same bags, same url except the ID is different: