I'm wondering how large sites like StackOverflow handle their access logs. A write to the disk on every request seems a little bit uneconomical, but is Google Analytics that reliable to use it as your only information resource?
-
You can set up Apache to log to a database. I imagine IIS is the same. – Lèse majesté Nov 2 '10 at 17:55
Add a comment
|
On a *nix system you could use syslog-ng to store log messages on a dedicated log server for your load-balanced cluster(s) and then use a log analysis solution like Splunk to keep tabs on things - as for what the StackExchange sites actually run, may be a good question for StackOverflow Meta.
There is much information that web server logs contain which will never be available to Google Analytics, two things I can think of:
- Errors like 404, etc.
- Access on media files, like pictures, etc. (including external websites linking to your images)
- IP addresses, although an answer to another question pointed out that it can be set as a user variable
- Full length referral URLs, for example Google sends links from product search, web search, etc. each search has keywords but Google Analytics does not display the other variables like
&source=products, etc.
Must be more stuff I just can't think of right now.
And there are also the error logs; must be important for a website to run smoothly, in my opinion. Not something you would ignore.
-
Thats right, but how do they store their logs? File or database as suggested by Lèse majesté seems to heavy to me. – KitKat Nov 2 '10 at 19:57
-
Actually, when you gzip this kind of repetitive data ... it compresses really well. So I imagine you can just store it as compressed text files and remove them after a while ... just your basic rotation. – Evgeny Nov 2 '10 at 22:09
I don't really look at these logs and end up deleting them on a monthly basis. I only look at them for trouble shooting. As for as monitoring application use Google Analytics, CrazyEgg and others do a great job.
Before such services existed these logs were very valuable. Now, they are good developer tools, but I don't know of any of my colleagues or friends that actively archive these logs or parse them for data.
