1

I have been using Google Analytics for long but i am still not convinced why Google Analytics reports less traffic than AWStats, even though i know AWStats reports traffic from bots, spiders etc..

My question is based on let us say i have two pages on website for which i want to measure traffic, so i am using both GA & AWStats

Below is the result of GA

PageName                 PageView
/edm/                    300       
/edm/campaign2.html      100

Traffic from AWStats (Pages-URL)

PageName                 Viewed
/edm/                    2000       
/edm/campaign2.html      400

Traffic reported by AWStats is almost 6 times more. so which one i should consider.

edm folder has two files in it one is index.html & other one is campaign2.html

If i add further details then under Days of month section it shows me traffic as (taken into cosideration that new page on website has been live since 15th August 18) and traffic stats which i provided are for 15th & 16th. and if you see under Page URL section it show page view as & below it still doesn't seem to add up as as i can understand below is for all pages not just the the two page i am looking for as accurate traffic

Date           Number of visits  Pages     Hits     Bandwidth
15 Aug 2018    1,311             4,727     17,974   2.72 GB
16 Aug 2018    70                178       902     178.13 MB

UPDATE

I would like to mention that these two page we where also tracking using bit.ly link and bit.ly stats match with AWstats which is surprising and traffic for both page on bit.ly stats show around 2,500 click on these link. So this is even creating more confusion, so did GA fail to record traffic properly

Below is the GA Analytics code which was added before the end of Body tag. did i do something wrong here

<script async src="https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=UA-xxxxxxx-xx"></script>
<script>
  window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer || [];
  function gtag(){dataLayer.push(arguments);}
  gtag('js', new Date());

  gtag('config', 'UA-xxxxxxx-xx');
</script>
  • 1
    AWStats uses your server's logs to compile its stats, Google Analytics uses JavaScript requests. There are pluses and minuses with both. With logs, it's difficult to determine what's a bot versus an actual visit/user. With JavaScript, browsers and ad blockers can disable it, and most bots won't process it. I'd suggest tracking changes between one versus both, so you're comparing apples with apples instead of apples with oranges. – dan Aug 16 '18 at 4:56
  • Yes, we are comparing apple & oranges but how can i guest accurate traffic based on current stat from both.. This pages where specifically designed sms campaign so user will open these page on mobile phone only. and user are do lazy to disable JS on their phone browser... So why should i consider as best traffic guess as AWstat has 6 times more traffic for same pages ?. So did google fail to record traffic even if JS is enabled on browser? – Learning Aug 16 '18 at 5:03
  • 1
    In regards to what you just edited in your comment: SO you mean to say if i include Google bot in Gooblebot is not the only bot, so no, that is not what I mean to say. There are countless bots crawling sites, some of which continously change IP's and user agents, so AWStats cannot account for those. – dan Aug 16 '18 at 5:46
  • 1
    URL shorteners track all clicks/requests, so they would naturally report higher numbers than AWStats, which does account for some bot traffic, but not all, so that does make sense. If you're focused on actual visitors/users, stick with Google Analytics, it's what most marketing professionals use. We've really over-reached this discussion, so hopefully you're clearer now. The question is kind of opinion-based, but I'll leave it open in case someone cares to elaborate with more specific details about the differences between the two. – dan Aug 16 '18 at 6:15
  • 1
    @dan, i appreciate your feedback, I am myself strong advocate of GA, which i consider for correct measurement of campaign. on the other-side i will add some percentage to GA traffic as analytics may be disabled on some browser – Learning Aug 16 '18 at 6:19

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.