Tell me more ×
Webmasters Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for pro webmasters. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Starting frOm tomorrow January/12/2012 I heard it's possible to apply for your own TLD i.e. .whatever in place of .com .org etc.

I thought it would be something required a huge amount of money, and not for everyone (i heard stories about paying $ 185K for one) but I found this company who seems to register a new TLD for just $ 1000, you can try by your self going on a bit in the registration:

http://tld.name/register-your-tld.php

And actually here is where they say the price:

The price to register a TLD including the unlimited number of domains that belong to it is: $1000.- only.

Do you think it's a joke or for real?

Do you know about other places where I can go to apply for personalized TLD?

share|improve this question

3 Answers

up vote 10 down vote accepted

The site you saw is run by Public-Root, one of the many alternative root zone operators. These are essentially rogue organizations that create/sell custom TLDs that aren't sanctioned or recognized by ICANN and only exist on their own private root DNS servers.

So, technically, they're right, you can buy a custom TLD from them for $1000. The only problem is that no one, not even you, will be able to resolve the TLD or any domains under that TLD because pretty much no ISPs use these alternative root DNS zones. Nearly all ISPs stick to ICANN's official DNS root.

Another problem with alternative root zones is that it allows different root zone operators to sell the same FQDN to different people, resolving to different servers. This happened when Pacific Root created .biz before ICANN sanctioned the creation of the .biz TLD. Later, when ICANN officially sanctioned .biz and delegated it to Neulevel's root servers, there became a conflict due to overlapping DNS records for .biz domains sold by Pacific Root and those sold by Neulevel. In effect, some people would type in foo.biz and it would resolve to one IP address as given by Pacific Root, while someone with a different ISP would get pointed to another IP as specified in Neulevel's official root servers.

Of course, this was gradually resolved as alternative root zones have pretty much been discounted (as evidenced by the horribly dated and poorly maintained self-promotional websites linked to Public-Root) since the use of alternative root zone would inevitably fracture and destabilize the internet. But this hasn't stopped these unethical companies from setting up semi-official-sounding organizations to link to using fake trustmarks (using early-90s-era graphics) and trying to scam unweary visitors out of their money.

share|improve this answer
+1 Agree, it's a scam. – blunders Jan 12 '12 at 5:32
2  
You seem to be right, searching the site if found this info tld.name/check.php , it kind of confirms what you wrote. – martinstoeckli Jan 12 '12 at 8:26

It does appear that ICANN will be allowing you to purchase your own TLD, but I would be incredibly skeptical of any company offering to sell you one - especially right now.

It looks like ICANN will start taking applications on Wednesday, Jan. 12th (tomorrow, on the date of this answer) and will be accepting applications up until April.

I have not been able to find a price from anywhere other than this TechCrunch Article about the new TLD decision, and that quotes the $185,000 figure as well.

It sounds like someone is trying to scam you out of $1000 - I'd be very wary!

EDIT: According to the Application Guidebook from the ICANN New gTLD site, the registration fee is indeed $185,000. Unless these registrars are kindly footing the bill for the initial cost, I would highly doubt their legitimacy.

If you're interested in applying for one, I'd say the ICANN program site will be your best bet.

If you are successful in your application, there are then ongoing fees (from FAQ 5.7):

  • A fixed fee of US$6,250 per calendar quarter
  • A transaction fee of US$0.25 (once you have more than 50,000 transactions per quarter/4 quarters)

There are also other fees that may be required during the registration process to cover the costs of arbitration panels if more than one person attempts to register a similar TLD.

share|improve this answer
Looks very real, but I like to see someone try it first – Eric Yin Jan 11 '12 at 20:08
2  
The registration fee is $185k, there are then quaterly fees on top of that just to maintain the domain, etc. – Zhaph - Ben Duguid Jan 18 '12 at 17:48

Owning a TLD shouldn't cost a penny, in fact as it goes the structure of the internet as everybody knows it today goes completely against the outset and format it was supposed to take and in fact did take when it was first realised.

The centralisation of domain name servers was actually never supposed to happen and is an abomination to internet and contrary to the way the internet was supposed work. To be connected by a peer to peer hop system. This system worked well in the early days however as people became a little more security concious things took a turn for the worse and thus domain name servers came into existence.

However, With some careful consideration and practical security measures, it is entirely possible to take the internet back to its roots especially with the massive leaps and bounds in security that have come about in the last 10 - 15 years.

To say that these organisations are a fraud or hacks or whatever you so wish to name them is actually laughing in the face of the internet and in fact, the hacks and frauds are the organisations that took over the job of running the internet with the blessing of the ISP's because it helped them to make money.

Host names were needed because of the way peoples minds work, written language works better than numbers, we remember them easier but the principle is the same. The internet was a very simple principle, packets of data get assigned an IP address to find and basically hop about the internet until it found its target machine and deliver its message.

Hostnames in fact do not need a domain name server to resolve them to an IP address, what they need is an algorithm that would be universal on every machine and every machine would use it so that when a Hostname is given to a machine, its IP address is generated from it. When a Hostname is typed into browser or any other program they used the internet the browser would instantly know the IP address because it would be using that very same algorithm that was initially used.

I know you will say that just anybody can create a Hostname, and so they should be able to. in order to authenticate a machine and its authority as being the true valid Hostname, the algorithm could simply take into account a serial number of the machine and thus eliminate the need for name servers.

The reason for governing bodies came into existence was initially to maintain some order in the Hostname creation and they simply took over the internet from there.

If they must exist to maintain the internet and keep things in order then I believe their only job should be to validate a Hostname, Let them send a key to a machine to create a Hostname, in this way they can still prevent false Hostnames being generated as long as the algorithm included a step that required a call to them.

All browsers would also do this check otherwise they couldn't generate a valid IP address, the one problem is this brings in a single point of failure but that too could be avoided if they had distributed servers for the job.

In essence this is a really simple process and the prevention, creation and verification of a Hostname, we already have a method in place that could be used. SSL certificates already do it and this could be used as a base for ensuring order elsewhere than just a secure connection.

I hope my very long ramble is informative and helpful. Sorry it went on so long but as you can see I am very passionate about this specific topic but in any case, have a nice day and i hope you enjoyed the read :)

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.