Tell me more ×
Webmasters Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for pro webmasters. It's 100% free, no registration required.
up vote 7 down vote favorite
1

Is this already acceptable in the Adsense ToS? (can't find any information on this specific case). If the user resizes the browser (css 3):

@media screen and (max-width: 980px) {
 #skyscraper { display: none; }
}

example at okcupid.com - large site

The idea is to present an horizontal-scroll-free site when the user resizes the browser window to 980px or less.

share|improve this question

3 Answers

up vote 2 down vote accepted

I think the terms of service refer to a situation where you load the ads but then do not display them to the visitors, hence mucking up view/click through stats. If you don't load the ad in the first place then it should be be OK. You'd have to do this with JavaScript rather than CSS though - detect the window width, only run the AdSense code if it's wider than a certain number.

share|improve this answer
good point! now i have to find out how to load adsense banners after the dom is ready. – andufo Oct 21 '11 at 22:14
up vote 3 down vote

You can't hide ads; it's in the AdSense terms and conditions under "5. Prohibited Uses":

You shall not, and shall not authorize or encourage any third party to: ... (ii) edit, modify, filter, truncate or change the order of the information contained in any Ad, Link, Ad Unit, Search Result, or Referral Button, or remove, obscure or minimize any Ad, Link, Ad Unit, Search Result, or Referral Button in any way without authorization from Google;

Seems pretty clear to me. (It's probably because the JavaScript code for the ad would still run, falsely reporting an ad view and stunting the click through rate.)

Moving the ad to the footer area for narrow screens using media queries might be safer.

share|improve this answer
hi for your answer nick. what i still don't understand is why okcupid (very large site) does it without consequences. – andufo Aug 19 '11 at 15:05
@andufo Maybe they got authorisation from Google. Or maybe they just haven't been caught yet. – Nick Aug 19 '11 at 15:17
alexa.com/siteinfo/okcupid.com it is a site with high traffic and very well ranked hehe, im betting on the authorization. – andufo Aug 19 '11 at 15:22
up vote 0 down vote

I don't know how things were when you posted your question, but as of now, Google actually recommends "responsive design" over any other option.

This document states that you can use @media queries clearly enough, although not in exact text. (You may also want to read this.) So, what you are doing IS okay.

And don't consider what I am saying baseless. Take Mashable, for example. They do that, and they are one of those top Adsense Premium Publishers.

Tl;dr - As of now, what you wanted to do is perfectly fine by the rules, as I see it.

share|improve this answer
Recommending "responsive design" is one thing, using media queries to hide AdSense is another. I don't think the Google docs you link to cover this? And Mashable does not do this, they still display the Ads, but in different parts of the page. – w3d Jan 12 at 14:03
@w3d Are you sure about what you are saying? 'cause I do see that Mashable uses this: @media (max-width: 969px){ .box970 .visible-desktop .ad_container.ad970 {display:none !important} } What does that say to you? :) – its_me Jan 12 at 15:43
That particular CSS relates to the wide header which, on the homepage at least, does not contain AdSense. All the AdSense on the page appears to remain as the viewport is shrunk. However, you are right, on other pages there is AdSense in the header and in the side panel and both are removed as the viewport shrinks. However, it is a bit more complicated than this. If the page is initially loaded at a small viewport size then the AdSense does not even load. Increasing the viewport size does not show the AdSense since it was never loaded. – w3d Jan 12 at 21:15
@Nick's answer still appears to be relevant, the AdSense T&Cs quoted are still current. Providing AdSense is not hidden after it has been loaded (which results in an impression) then it's OK. AFAIK mobile users do not resize their viewport. The edge case on Mashable where the browser window is shrunk (on desktop) and the AdSense is removed might have been overlooked or they have gotten permission from Google, I don't know. In most cases, however, they do appear to follow the T&Cs. – w3d Jan 12 at 21:24
@w3d I must ask you to read the reply from a top contributor on the Google Adsense forums. – its_me Feb 3 at 10:09

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.