what are benefits of URL rewriting?

Question

URL rewriting has become quite popular but I think it only adds more complexity to the Web. They call the old fashioned URL's, "dirty URL" so I'll use that term.

They argue that with rewriting, it makes the URL more "discoverable" but how is it more discoverable with this URL

www.magic.com/date/2010/02/02 

than this?

www.magic.com/date=2010-02-02

I would think people would discover more with the old fashioned URL than the rewrite URL.

With the good old fashioned URL using ampersands and equal signs, you are actually telling the search engines how they relate to each other. With slashes, you can't. They don't know that /2010/02/02 is actually a date or how the numbers relate to the /date/. It merely assumes that it's a different directory with different data. With date=2010-02-02, I'd think it'll allow search engines to figure out how they relate to each other.

Dirty URL's can easily be shortened with URL shortner services but everyone copies URL and paste it, not write it. It's much easier if they write down the dirty URL that's well laid out. goo.gl/8aPtuI seems more cognitively difficult than generic.com/awesome.

I read argument that search engines stop at URLs that look dynamically generated and I am skeptical. Virtually all websites are dynamically created so why would they stop there? It doesn't make sense.

I'd also think that dirty URL's can be meta-rich if you do it right.

www.generic.com/rate=5&name=Allen&sex=m 

and it's much easier for engines to see how they are related than doing this,

www.generic/com/rate/5/name/Allen/sex/m. 

I'd like to know what the real advantages are.

Answer 1

I wouldn't so much call it "URL rewriting" so much as "having a sane URL schema". There is a good and bad place for everything.

In the example you give, you are absolutely correct; you have an unordered set of 'parameters' as it were, and the key=value&key2=value2&... syntax is excellent for that.

However with the date example you give, there is a nice hierarchical structure. So for example if your site had a monthly listing, you could do www.magic.com/date/2010/02 for an index page with choice of days, or a yearly listing you could do www.magic.com/date/2010 for an index of months (and maybe a sidebar with days), and www.magic.com/date for an index of years and/or something similar.

It all comes down to what is elegant. Unnecessary URL rewriting (you gave a perfect example) can be as inelegant as a path shoved into key=value query. And only savvy users will bother manually rewriting the URL.

As some other answers point out though, one should take care not to leak internals. For example it is very bad practice to do /mypage.ext?internalThing=blah&... because then everyone knows you're using ext. You should not show the extension of your script. Let's say you want to change mypage.php to mypage.py or something; then (as other answers suggest) this will confuse search engines. This is a separate concern than URL rewriting though; for example it would be just as bad to do /mypage.ext/category. It is probably just a correlation that the people who aren't aware of URL rewriting also aren't aware that /mypage.ext?... links are bad practice.

On the other hand, URL rewriting can require integration with the web server, which may be time better spent on other things.

Answer 2

When I was learning about URL rewriting, I found some good articles

An Overview of URL Rewriting and Its Benefits

URL rewriting - benefits and implications

Also:

1. SEO friendly. If re re engineer the site lets say from asp to aspx then we can keep the same extension but use different technology, so old site rating and ranking remains the same

2. Powers the developers for rapid development of web applications or websites. Lets say we have content pages that we manage from CMS and based on them we show in front end, in earlier days we have to create pages at front end but using the URL rewriting we create single page at front end and use URL re writing to inter prate as n different pages

3. Security: It will make site more secure as malicious user will not be able to get to know the structure of the application

4. We avoid the query-string and use URL rewriting to pass on data among various page calls

Answer 3

One good opinion I like:

"I think the prime reasons are usability and search engine optimization. From the SEO perspective, I think you can get keywords into the URL rather than ID#'s. For your users, it is easier to navigat a site with:

mysite.com/products/tools/hammers/stanley

than:

mysite.com/products.aspx?id=43245&cat=33&subcat=867&manfuacturer=854

The user can just take off sections of the URL to navigate up a level. I am sure there are a lot of other goof reasons, but those are some main ones."

And from security point of view:

It will make site more secure as malicious user will not be able to get to know the structure of the application

And a quote from Google Blog:

Keep in mind, however, that dynamic URLs with a large number of parameters may be problematic for search engine crawlers in general, so rewriting dynamic URLs into user-friendly versions is always a good practice when that option is available to you. If you can, keeping the number of URL parameters to one or two may make it more likely that search engines will crawl your dynamic urls.